Did you cry in All Hell Breaks Loose?

[Fibs]

I cried when Piper died... It was just sooo sad, when Leo and Prue was crying...

[Ms. Halliwell]

Yes, I cried too

[phoebe4ever]

I cried when Piper died and when Prue was smashed through the wall with Piper and they both lay there. It was like a waterfall!

[MagicalEdgemaster5]

I'm gonna be honest with ya. I'm not stone cold when it comes to getting emotionally moved, but I'm not the guaranteed-to-get-soppy kinda guy either. And I didn't really get to fully watch All Hell Breaks Loose until after I found out Prue died and got replaced by Paige. After watching just to see exactly how it came to happen, I gotta say with certainty, never in the history of my time watching Charmed have I been more horrified or brought to tears than I did watching that episode and seeing just how everything happened. Especially when Piper died such a bloody, horrible death at the hands of a crazy lady's bullet. That just turned my stomach.

Nov 9, 2006 15:59:42 GMT -5 aerokinesis said:

Hell hath no fury was sad but it was more of an episode to finish off prue, cus without the clsoure piper got prue would have been talked about alot more, which woiuld not neccesarily have been a bda thing

Beg to differ. Would've made her look like an obsessed junkie who can't move on and do anything without Prue. Notice what happened in Cole's self-designed alternate future until she met Paige?

[Cheali]

I do not believe i cried in this episode, but probably because i knew that Prue was going to die since i watched Charmed in a weird way . I think i was watching the 5th season by the times the 3rd started. I started watching the 1st on one channel, than the 4th started on another channel aboubtu a year later. So i got to watch two season at once. I have since then watched all the episodes in order . I know this is a bit of a weird way to watch it, lol. I guess knowing what was to come made it not sad for me or something?

[Peanut]

I cried in this episode when Piper died because I thought she was gone for real. I had no idea that Prue was going to sacrifice herself. I got mad when Prue died because I thought all three women brought something to the show.

[deleted account]

i didnt cry but it was so sad
i didnt want prue 2 die =(

[piper113]

ya i cried when piper died

[piperhalliwell95]

i dident cry but when piper died it was sad and leos reaction was sad

[deleted account]

nah but i was lil teary it was sooo sad

[PiperandHolly]

yes i cried when piper died it was so sad the way piper was talking and prue's reaction

[halliwellwyatt]

I cried through most of that!

[HollyMarieFan]

yes i cried when piper died i just thought shannen acted really well in that and it just made me cry but i didnt cry when prue died and i dont really know why

[Petra Marie Halliwell]

I didn't see the whole entire episodes because I haven't had the chance to actually witness one. But I've seen clips of the episode, especially Piper's death. Prue's death wasn't dramatic, IMO. D:

[xScenexQueenx]

Yea, I cried when Piper died, but Prue's never been my favorite character.