|
Post by kendall on May 1, 2008 16:45:40 GMT -5
sorry to everybody who likes shannen, but i thinks she was a butthead. every show she works on, she causes drama and ends up leaving the show that she was working on.
|
|
|
Post by Billie girl on May 1, 2008 17:36:24 GMT -5
I donno, i think i wonder what it would have been like had she of stayed, but i don't think i'd want a single thing to change ya know?
|
|
|
Post by Piper Halliwell on May 2, 2008 9:17:11 GMT -5
I'm not sure i would have liked her to stay for a couple more seasons
|
|
Pacey
New witch
Posts: 75
|
Post by Pacey on Jun 21, 2008 7:02:24 GMT -5
Definitely! What can I say ... I'm a Prue/Shannen fan so I would've loved to have seen more of her on Charmed.
|
|
|
Post by Lisa on Jun 21, 2008 9:01:24 GMT -5
Yeah they could have shown her as a ghost like Grams and Patty.
|
|
|
Post by iheartpaige on Jun 29, 2008 19:41:12 GMT -5
absolutly no way! how would they sove heaps of demons crimes without her premonitions and it wouldnt make sense!
|
|
|
Post by pruepiperphoebe on Jul 26, 2008 23:39:11 GMT -5
No way on Earth, Alyssa was meant to play Phoebe. I'am so glad she stayed on. Shannen was meant to play Prue.
|
|
|
Post by pruepiperphoebe on Jul 26, 2008 23:40:11 GMT -5
Alyssa plays Phoebe well. I don't think she should have left. Shannen plays Prue well.
|
|
|
Post by pruepiperphoebe on Jul 26, 2008 23:41:57 GMT -5
i love shannen and i love alyssa neither should have left the power of three was best with prue and it wouldn't be any better if alyssa left and its not the same since shannen left. I agree. I loved the original Charmed Ones. Prue, Piper, and Phoebe were the best. The chemistry was so much better. There should have never been a replacement.
|
|
|
Post by pruepiperphoebe on Jul 26, 2008 23:46:59 GMT -5
Prue leaving changed the entire dynamic of the show. It thrust all of the girls into a different position in their family. If Prue had stayed and Phoebe had left nothing would have changed for Piper and Prue. All that would have happened to them was another baby sister who is vivacious and flirty. But would still have been the same show. By Prue leaving Piper had to take over and instead of being the peacemaker she had to be the decision maker. Phoebe had to stop being the baby and fill Piper's shoes. This took everything in a different direction. A good direction from my standpoint. Until they started runing out of storylines. Which is inevitable in such a long running show. They would have run out of storylines alot faster keeping Prue. I loved all of the sisters, each for her unique qualities that she brought to the canvas. But if one had to go it had to be Prue. That's not true about them running out of stories. Heck, Paige being the new sister only lasted for about a couple of shows. Buffy lasted for a long time and none of the major characters (Buffy, Giles, Zander, and Willow) left or wer replaced. If anything, Charm lost viewers when Shannen left. The show starting going downhill, becoming cartoonish and silly. There could have been plenty of storylines if Prue had stayed on the show. That's what writers are for, to write new story ideas, and having new demons or new guest stars keeps the show fresh as well. Prue being the oldest had nothing to do with keeping things fresh.
|
|
|
Post by pruepiperphoebe on Jul 26, 2008 23:50:05 GMT -5
No way Aylssa is way better than Shannon and I don't think the show would have lasted as long as it has if Shannon stay The show would have still lasted. It just would have went out with more dignity.
|
|
|
Post by pruepiperphoebe on Jul 26, 2008 23:56:27 GMT -5
Honestly, I don't think that Charmed would have gone on as long if Alyssa had left. A big part of the show is the whole sisterly dynamic. Apparently the dynamic with Piper, Phoebe, and Paige worked very well. It was great. But it probably wouldn't have been the same with Prue, Piper, and Paige. But who knows! Well, if a big part of Charmed was the whole sisterly dynamic then it would have worked with Prue, since she is a sister. Many people didn't watch or continue watching because Piper, Phoebe, and Paige "worked very well," many watched or continued watching because they liked Cole and Phoebe as a couple or Piper and Leo as a couple, or because they liked, Piper, Phoebe, Leo, or Cole, so any of the sisters would have been okay, as long as there were still two original Charmed ones who stayed on the show.
|
|
|
Post by pruepiperphoebe on Jul 26, 2008 23:59:31 GMT -5
Yes agreed and I had never even heard of Shannen till Charmed I always watched Who's the boss because 90210 wasn't the best show except for i think his name was luke perry he's hott lol! but anyways Holly and Shannen were best friends but Holly and Alyssa grew as friends aswell and i do agree that they are both big stars but they really aren't bigger then each toher because most people ahve heard of Alyssa and the other most of them have heard of Shannen that is a no win situation but i think if Alyssa would ahve left many more would have stopped watching Charmed and i know i'm one of them use Prue was a great asset to the show but i think it would have stopped maybe a season or 2 later if Alyssa would have left instead. Well, and I and many others did quit watching after Shannen left.
|
|
|
Post by pruepiperphoebe on Jul 27, 2008 0:01:42 GMT -5
Shannon was jealous of all the attention alyssa was getting to do commericals. if they couldn't get along you get rid of the one making all the waves.. Looks like that's what the did and they went on for 5 more seasons. The show would have went for 5 more seasons as long as two of the original Charmed Ones stayed on the show, whether it be Prue and Piper, or Prue and Phoebe. However, at least with Shannen the show may have left with some dignity.
|
|
|
Post by pruepiperphoebe on Jul 27, 2008 0:04:41 GMT -5
I voted No Way. The show would not have been Charmed without Alyssa. With Shannon leaving they brought in Paige and the chemisty between everybody just seemed so perfect. The chemistry between Prue, Piper, and Phoebe was perfect. The show was a successful hit BEFORE Paige entered the picture. Paige never seemed like a sister. She was more of an outsider, and Piper and Phoebe treated her like an outsider. Plus, Paige did not look like Phoebe and Piper's sister, and she did not fit as a baby sister. She looked older than Phoebe. The chemistry was perfect between Piper, Prue, and Phoebe. Paige looked too tall, in my opinion.
|
|