Was it fair the way Prue died?

[HollymCombs]

Was it fair the way Prue died? They really just had her fly through a wall, and then they showed her laying there, and the next thing we knew they were at her funeral. Do you think that she deserved more than that?

[Alyssa]

I would really wanna see what happened between this...

[AngelPiper1329]

me too it would have explained alot and gave me more peace to her death i cried like a baby when prue died but was confused at the end of all hell breaks loose after i saw the funeral i thought i missed the episode where she died it was really confusing but i eventually figured it out and wasn't too happy how it happened and still am not.

[Charmed Forever]

Me too they should have shown a bit more than just her being injured by being thrown through a wall and her funeral even though it was really sad

[pheebz101]

i think they shouldve shown more because they didnt really concluded phoebes trade or anything. i mean im not a prue fan but it was unfair that she didnt have a full dealth scene

[*DarkPhoenix*]

Totally unfair..not just to Prue but to Shannen as well.I, liek a few others said here thought I had missed an episode. Especially since I expected more of an explanation as to how Phoebe got out of the underworld and well you know. I dunno Prue deserved more than that although the episode is still one of the best Charmed has ever produced IMO. Great swansong for Shannen.

[Forever Phoebe]

no it was not fair! she should have died saving the doctor!!!!! and she shouldn't have died because she hit the wall!!!!!!!!!!!

[*DarkPhoenix*]

Tho to be fair she did die saving Dr. Griffiths..the consequence of savign him was that she was thrown through the wall. And yeah I know he still died but still she saved him at the point she threw herself infront of the energy ball. So IMO she did die saving him, the consequence was that she received head injuries from beign thrown through the wall.

[Forever Phoebe]

i ment she should have died and because she died he should have lived!

[pruefan4eva]

i also thought i'd missed an episode i was really upset but it's always Charmed Again Part 1 and Hell Hath No Fury that makes me almost cry.

i would also like an explanation of how Phoebe got out of Underworld. It was a bad death for her, she deserved better. like Piper says in Charmed Again, she was the super witch.

[prudence72]

the way that they let Shannen go was absolutely unprofessional. I still cannot believe that they did that to her. And then the way that they just wrote Prue off... it was awful. No explanation, no mention of her hardly since then, no pictures, no nothing. It was absolutely horrible.

[miraclebaby]

foreverphoebe said:

i ment she should have died and because she died he should have lived!

Good afternoon. ^_^ I agree. She died in an unfair way. She died in vain!

[PipernChristyAngel]

i don't think that was fair the way how she died.

[*DarkPhoenix*]

Totally agree with everything said. And I do agree that because she sacrificed herself the doctor should have lived. And the way she "left" the show I think completely justifies her reasoning for not wnating to return..and to be fair even though the fans may want it..I for one wouldn't expect her to return to a show run by people who treated her with absolutely no respect at all, regardless of her relationship or lack of one with any member of the cast.

[hollymarie12541699]

i dont think it is fair the way she died. i think that they need a filler.