|
Post by HollymCombs on Mar 6, 2006 15:17:16 GMT -5
Would Phoebe make a good mom?
|
|
askphoebe
New witch
See beyond the future...
Posts: 50
|
Post by askphoebe on Mar 23, 2006 23:10:49 GMT -5
o think she would make an awesome mother i wish she would adopt me!
|
|
|
Post by charmedlover1 on Mar 28, 2006 6:18:57 GMT -5
phoebe would be a great mum but piper would always be the best to me
|
|
|
Post by *DarkPhoenix* on Mar 28, 2006 16:14:51 GMT -5
No. Personally I find her too selfish. But if you know me you know Im not so hot on Phoebe's character ever since Season 5. So dont flame me lol! I dont think that Phoebe could ever care about a child more than herself. To me she has proven she only cares about herself many times. This is just my opinion and I dunno its good to have a different one sometimes I think. So if you disagree fine but yeah.
|
|
askphoebe
New witch
See beyond the future...
Posts: 50
|
Post by askphoebe on Mar 28, 2006 19:29:38 GMT -5
No. Personally I find her too selfish. But if you know me you know Im not so hot on Phoebe's character ever since Season 5. So dont flame me lol! I dont think that Phoebe could ever care about a child more than herself. To me she has proven she only cares about herself many times. This is just my opinion and I dunno its good to have a different one sometimes I think. So if you disagree fine but yeah. No offense but i think you are way off she would make a great mom. where did you get the idea that she would be a bad mother she is not selfish, what is she doing right now in these season looking for love so that she can have her baby the baby she wants more than anything else in the world. there is no way that phoebe is selfish. she cares about so may more people than herself look at all the innocents she has saved i mean, i think that you need to look closely at phoebe she has risked her life so many times to save the lives of others that she did not even know. in season five to savve a womans job she wrote her whole column in season one she saved a guy from getting run over. so i think she cares way more about other people than herself and would make a a great mother maybe not as good as piper but a better mother than what paige would be if she ever had kids.
|
|
|
Post by *DarkPhoenix* on Mar 29, 2006 7:42:21 GMT -5
^Okay fair enough you dont think she is selfish but I do and its not necessarily way off. Its my opinion of her I used to love her right up until the end of Season Four and then she seemed to be more focused on which guy she was dating and how inconvienet it was that a demon happened to attack during her date. Fair enough she is allowed to have a normal life but for me she is a selfish character, and Im just expressing my opinion on that. Yeah but I think that she shouldn't be looking for love in the sense of only doing it because she wants a baby whihc is the reason I feel she is doing it for, it shouldn't happen that way. And for me the past three or so years has focused all on Phoebe and her eternal quest for a child. And sometimes yeah I think she is selfish, and I appreciate that you dont but I dont tell you that you are way off in thinking that she isn't.I mean she made sucha big fuss about Piper and Leo moving out of the Manor in Season Three. Yet when Phoebe wants to do it it's fine for her to do it because she wants to..and Im sorry if you don't agree. Aswell I have only seen a few from Season Eight so she may have changed since episode 10..but Paige relaised that she still had the calling to help the innocents coz of her Whitelighter half but Phoebe was pretty much near enough stuff them it isnt our problem anymore. And she basically blasted Piage for it. So yes In my opinion she is selfish and thats an opinion I cna justify and am entitled to.
And as I stated I found Phoebe a great character up until Season Five..and if you know who my favourite character in Charme dis it may explain why I am less fond of Phoebe than I used to be. Call that a biased judgement but hey ..thats how I feel and sometimes I ahev moments of liking Phoebe again..but for me ever since season 5 the show has become the Phoebe Halliwell show and i dunno...thats my opinion and if I wanted to "look closely" at her character I would but frankly what I see of her is enough to justify my views on the character.
|
|
|
Post by AskPhoebe2 on Mar 30, 2006 16:15:50 GMT -5
she would be the best....she said numerous times that she loves kids...and she was obsessed with wyatt when he was born
|
|
|
Post by *DarkPhoenix* on Mar 31, 2006 2:46:06 GMT -5
^See for me that was weird. Not that she was obsessed with him but the way she acted round him. Maybe thats just coz Ive never seen anyone act that way over a kid. I have been watching ym season four DVD's again..and Im kinda liking Pheebs a bit more since rewatchign those...so once I rewatch Season 5 I'll let ya know how I feel about it then.
|
|
|
Post by AngelPiper1329 on Apr 4, 2006 17:14:26 GMT -5
phoebe would be a great mother she would do anything for her child like she did for wyatt and even chris shes very lving and gives her whole heart she would make a perfect mother and as other people have said piper is the best mother (hey shes my fav character what can i say) but phoebe comes at a very very close second.
|
|
|
Post by Melinda Halliwell-Turner on Apr 6, 2006 13:55:56 GMT -5
Yes she would make the best mom ever!! That is my answer.
|
|
|
Post by pheebz101 on Apr 7, 2006 18:51:36 GMT -5
i think fever rose has a point bout her making a fuss bout leo and piper moving out. i thought that was unlike her. but i still think she'd make a terrific mother.and i know we all have fav characters and our own opionion so i wont nag feverrose for her choice.i mean i dont like prue or billie.
|
|
|
Post by Forever Phoebe on Apr 11, 2006 18:15:54 GMT -5
i totally dissagree with what FeverRose has to say! Phoebe would make a great mom! and she is totally not selfish! i mean in season 4, she wanted to save Paige, if it was up to Piper, they would have let Paige die! so how can you say she's selfish? i won't deny that she has done some pretty selfish things, but haven't we all? isn't that what makes the characters seem real! and now she's not only looking for true love, but she spent to whole first half of the season helping Billie find her sister! how is that selfish? giving up time to help Billie, when she could have just as easily let Billie find her sister on her own! So she was "obsessed with Wyatt" as you said when he was born! but that's only because what Phoebe wanted more than anything in the world was a child of her own! we see that in season two in " Reckless Abandon". Phoebe says and i quote "Yeah, I can’t wait to have a baby of my own some day." That was Phoebe not Piper! and Phoebe knew just what to do, to get the baby to stop crying at the police station, where as Piper had no idea what she was doing with him. She called Dan to help her because she didn't know what to do! Now i am not saying that Piper isn't the best mother in the world! don't get me wrong here! i love Piper and i do think she is the best mother in the world but even Piper got off to a rocky start with wyatt! she didn't "connect" as they say, with him right away! where as Phoebe did! so how can you say she won't be a good mother?
|
|
|
Post by prudence28 on Apr 18, 2006 13:13:28 GMT -5
yeah Pheobe would be an Awesome mom!
|
|
|
Post by *DarkPhoenix* on Apr 26, 2006 5:20:04 GMT -5
i totally dissagree with what FeverRose has to say! Phoebe would make a great mom! and she is totally not selfish! i mean in season 4, she wanted to save Paige, if it was up to Piper, they would have let Paige die! so how can you say she's selfish? i won't deny that she has done some pretty selfish things, but haven't we all? isn't that what makes the characters seem real! and now she's not only looking for true love, but she spent to whole first half of the season helping Billie find her sister! how is that selfish? giving up time to help Billie, when she could have just as easily let Billie find her sister on her own! So she was "obsessed with Wyatt" as you said when he was born! but that's only because what Phoebe wanted more than anything in the world was a child of her own! we see that in season two in " Reckless Abandon". Phoebe says and i quote "Yeah, I can’t wait to have a baby of my own some day." That was Phoebe not Piper! and Phoebe knew just what to do, to get the baby to stop crying at the police station, where as Piper had no idea what she was doing with him. She called Dan to help her because she didn't know what to do! Now i am not saying that Piper isn't the best mother in the world! don't get me wrong here! i love Piper and i do think she is the best mother in the world but even Piper got off to a rocky start with wyatt! she didn't "connect" as they say, with him right away! where as Phoebe did! so how can you say she won't be a good mother? I agree with Pheebs being unselfish in SDeason four. I liked her up unbtil season five, before that she was probably not my fave character but I prefered her to Piper definatley.Look the fact of the matter is is that my opinion is that she would'nt be. Im sure that there are things I will think about certain characters that other people wont think.Its not the fact that she is selfish for wanting a baby, it is the fact that for me she has recently thought of nothing else, and whilst that is fine for her to feel that way. IMO she has let some of her other responsibilities etc slide. I mean I liek a good debate as muchas the next person but I dont appreciate being told that my opinion is wrong just because someone else thinks it is. Your opinions are just as much correct as mine are. Not everyone can liek the same character you know. And I personally dislike Phoebe - but thats my choice.
|
|
|
Post by Forever Phoebe on Apr 26, 2006 18:03:07 GMT -5
(ooc. sorry i didn't think i ever said you were wrong! i was just saying that i disagreed and that she wasn't being selfish)
I totally get what your saying, but... I think after all she's been through she diserves a baby! and i don't think she was being selfish in the 5th season i think she was in the 6th though!
|
|